Is Your Divorce Settlement Really Fair? A Certified Divorce Financial Analyst Explains the 10 Financial Tests Every Marital Settlement Agreement Should Pass

By Sue Plisch, CFP®, CDFA®

Certified Divorce Financial Analyst and Founder of Resilient Divorce Solutions, LLC

One of the most common things I hear from clients is:

“We agreed to split everything fifty-fifty, so I think it’s fair.”

Sometimes it is.

Many times, it is not.

In fact, one of the biggest financial mistakes people make during divorce is assuming that an equal division of assets automatically means an equitable outcome.

Divorce is one of the largest financial transactions most people will ever experience. Yet many people spend more time researching a new vehicle than they spend evaluating a marital settlement agreement worth hundreds of thousands or even millions of dollars.

The decisions you make during your divorce can affect your finances for decades.

As a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst (CDFA®), I have seen settlement agreements that looked perfectly reasonable on the surface but contained financial problems that were not obvious until someone carefully analyzed the numbers.

The good news is that these problems are often avoidable.

This article will walk through the first five financial tests I use when evaluating whether a proposed Marital Settlement Agreement is truly fair from a financial perspective.

What Does “Fair” Really Mean?

Fair does not necessarily mean equal.

A financially sound divorce settlement should help both spouses move forward with a realistic opportunity to build financial stability.

Research consistently shows that many divorcing spouses, particularly those who spent years caring for children or earning less income, experience substantial declines in their standard of living after divorce.

One study published in the Journal of Family and Economic Issues found that women often experience significantly larger financial losses than men following divorce, particularly when they were the lower earning spouse during the marriage.

That does not mean every higher earning spouse should pay more. It means that a good settlement considers each person’s complete financial picture rather than simply dividing assets in half.

When reviewing divorce finances, I encourage clients to think about what their life will look like one year, five years, and even twenty years after signing the agreement.

Financial Test Number One

Is Every Asset and Debt Included?

This may sound obvious.

Unfortunately, it is surprisingly common for assets to be unintentionally overlooked.

A complete inventory should include:

  • Checking accounts
  • Savings accounts
  • Investment accounts
  • Retirement accounts
  • Pensions
  • Stock options
  • Restricted stock
  • Businesses
  • Real estate
  • Vehicles
  • Credit cards
  • Personal loans
  • Home equity lines
  • Health Savings Accounts
  • Cryptocurrency
  • Reward points
  • Deferred compensation
  • Valuable collections

Even small omissions can create large inequities over time.

One missing retirement account today could represent tens of thousands of dollars at retirement.

Financial Test Number Two

Are You Comparing True Value Instead of Face Value?

This is one of the biggest mistakes I see.

Two assets worth one hundred thousand dollars are often not worth the same.

A checking account worth one hundred thousand dollars is immediately available.

A traditional 401(k) worth one hundred thousand dollars may eventually lose twenty to thirty percent or more to taxes depending on future tax rates and withdrawals.

Rental property may come with capital gains taxes.

A pension may not begin paying for many years.

Stock options may never fully vest.

Looking only at account balances can create an illusion of fairness.

A Real Client Story

A highly educated couple came to me after they had already negotiated nearly every part of their divorce.

They had carefully divided almost every marital asset equally.

Then they decided something that seemed perfectly reasonable.

He would keep all of his retirement accounts.

She would keep all of hers.

Everyone involved believed the division was fair.

When I completed a comprehensive analysis, I found something surprising.

The husband had consistently earned significantly more throughout the marriage and had accumulated much larger retirement balances.

Even though each person kept “their own retirement,” the higher earning spouse would ultimately receive well over one hundred thousand dollars more in retirement assets.

When I adjusted those retirement accounts for estimated future taxes, the difference became even larger.

No one had intended to create an unfair outcome.

They simply had not looked at the entire financial picture.

That is why a comprehensive divorce finance analysis is so valuable.

Financial Test Number Three

Will Both People Have Enough Monthly Cash Flow?

Receiving valuable assets does not necessarily mean you can pay next month’s bills.

Imagine receiving:

  • A paid off house
  • Retirement accounts
  • Land

Those assets may create an impressive balance sheet.

They do not automatically create monthly income.

When reviewing a settlement, ask questions like:

  • Can I comfortably pay my monthly expenses?
  • What happens after maintenance ends?
  • Can I replace my vehicle when needed?
  • Can I save for retirement?
  • Can I build an emergency fund?
  • Can I afford health insurance?
  • What happens if inflation continues?

One of the most valuable things a Divorce Financial Advisor can do is prepare realistic post-divorce cash flow projections.

Sometimes small changes in the settlement can dramatically improve long-term financial stability.

Financial Test Number Four

Can You Truly Afford the House?

Many people understandably want to keep the family home.

Sometimes it is absolutely the right decision.

Sometimes it becomes a financial burden that creates years of stress.

Owning a home involves much more than making the mortgage payment.

Consider:

  • Property taxes
  • Homeowners insurance
  • Repairs
  • Roof replacement
  • HVAC replacement
  • Landscaping
  • Utilities
  • HOA fees
  • Future refinancing
  • Emergency repairs

I often encourage clients to think beyond today’s emotions.

Ask yourself:

“If I were buying a home today, would I choose this house at this price with my future income?”

If the answer is no, it may be worth exploring other options.

Research consistently shows that housing affordability is one of the biggest financial challenges following divorce.

Financial Test Number Five

Are Retirement Assets Being Divided Fairly?

For many couples, retirement accounts represent their largest marital asset.

Yet they are often among the least understood.

A fair division considers:

  • Tax treatment
  • Future growth
  • Pension valuation
  • QDRO requirements
  • Survivor benefits
  • Investment risk
  • Retirement age
  • Social Security implications

One research paper published in Family Law noted that pensions are frequently undervalued or misunderstood during divorce negotiations despite representing one of the most valuable marital assets.

Simply agreeing that “you keep yours and I’ll keep mine” can produce dramatically different outcomes.

Every retirement account should be viewed as part of one complete financial picture.

Research Supports Looking Beyond Equal Division

Research from the National Institutes of Health has found that divorce frequently produces long lasting reductions in wealth and retirement security.

Another large study found that the financial consequences of divorce continue for many years, especially for spouses who interrupted careers to raise children.

These findings reinforce something I see regularly in my practice.

Good divorce planning is not about winning.

It is about creating two financially sustainable futures.

Financial Test Number Six

Does the Agreement Actually Protect You From Debt?

Many people assume that if a divorce decree says one spouse is responsible for paying a debt, the other spouse is completely protected.

Unfortunately, that is not always true.

A divorce agreement is a contract between the spouses. It does not change the agreement that already exists with the lender.

If both spouses signed the original loan, the lender may still pursue either person if payments stop.

A Story That Illustrates the Problem

I once heard about a settlement agreement that required the husband to pay a off a substantial credit card debt that was solely in the wife’s name.

At first glance, that sounded reasonable.

There was just one problem.

His name was not on the account.

Because he was not an account holder, the credit card company would not even discuss the account with him.

He could not obtain statements.

He could not verify the balance or if additional charges were being made.

Imagine trying to comply with a court order while having no legal authority to manage the account.

That situation created unnecessary confusion and increased the likelihood of future conflict.

Whenever possible, I encourage clients to ask questions such as:

  • Whose name is on the debt?
  • Can one spouse remove the other’s name?
  • What happens if payments are missed?  Whose credit score takes the hit?
  • Can the account be paid off and closed right now before issues occur?
  • Is there a deadline for paying off joint debt?

The clearer the agreement, the fewer problems tend to arise later.

Financial Test Number Seven

Have You Considered the Tax Consequences?

Taxes rarely receive the attention they deserve during divorce.

Yet taxes can dramatically change the value of a settlement.

For example:

  • Traditional retirement accounts are generally taxable when withdrawn.
  • Roth retirement accounts may provide tax free withdrawals if requirements are met.
  • Investment accounts may trigger capital gains taxes.
  • Businesses may have hidden tax liabilities.
  • Selling a home may have tax implications depending on timing and appreciation.
  • For maintenance orders entered after December 31, 2018, maintenance is not tax deductible for the payor and is not taxable to the recipient on federal tax returns. Child support remains neither tax deductible nor taxable.

A settlement that appears perfectly balanced before taxes may become significantly unbalanced after taxes.

One of my favorite sayings is this:

“The IRS does not care whether your settlement looked fair on paper.”

When comparing assets, always compare after tax value, not simply account balances.

Financial Test Number Eight

Does the Agreement Allocate Risk Fairly?

Not all assets carry the same level of risk.

For example:

  • Cash is relatively stable.
  • Stocks fluctuate.
  • Small businesses may increase or decrease dramatically in value.
  • Rental properties require ongoing maintenance.
  • Pensions depend upon future payments.
  • Stock options may never become valuable.

Ask yourself:

Who is receiving the predictable assets?

Who is receiving the risky assets?

Sometimes one spouse receives assets that are stable and easy to access while the other receives assets that may take years to realize or that could lose value.

A fair settlement should recognize those differences.

Financial Test Number Nine

Is the Agreement Specific Enough to Prevent Future Conflict?

One of the most valuable things a well written Marital Settlement Agreement can do is prevent future disagreements.

Vague language often leads to expensive litigation.

A strong agreement answers questions such as:

  • Who prepares the Qualified Domestic Relations Order?
  • Who pays for it?
  • When must retirement accounts be divided?
  • When must the house be refinanced?
  • What happens if refinancing is not possible?
  • When will the home be listed for sale?
  • How will unexpected expenses be handled?
  • What happens if someone misses a deadline?

Specific language reduces uncertainty.

And reducing uncertainty often reduces attorney fees later.

Financial Test Number Ten

Have You Looked Beyond Today?

Perhaps the biggest mistake people make is focusing only on getting through the divorce.

That is understandable.

Divorce is emotionally exhausting.

But a settlement agreement should not simply solve today’s problems.

It should support your future.

I often ask clients to imagine themselves five years from now.

Can they comfortably pay their bills?

Can they retire someday?

Can they help their children with college?

Can they replace a furnace or vehicle without going into debt?

Can they build savings again?

These questions often reveal opportunities to improve a settlement before it becomes final.

When Hiring a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst Saves Far More Than It Costs

One of the questions I hear most often is:

“Can a Divorce Financial Advisor really save me money?”

In many cases, the answer is yes.

A Certified Divorce Financial Analyst is trained to evaluate the financial consequences of settlement options before they become permanent.

That analysis can uncover issues that are easy to miss, including:

  • Unequal retirement divisions
  • Tax consequences
  • Pension valuation issues
  • Child support scenarios
  • Maintenance options
  • Long term cash flow
  • House affordability
  • College planning
  • Investment implications
  • Settlement proposals that appear equal but produce very different outcomes

In my own practice, I have seen analyses identify settlement differences worth tens of thousands of dollars.

Occasionally, the difference has exceeded multiple hundreds of thousands of dollars.

When viewed from that perspective, the cost of financial analysis is often very small compared with the financial mistakes it helps prevent.

Just as importantly, clients frequently tell me something else.

They gain confidence.

Instead of wondering whether they made the right decision, they understand why they made it.

That peace of mind is difficult to place a price on.

A Divorce Settlement Fairness Checklist

Before signing your Marital Settlement Agreement, ask yourself these questions.

☐ Have all assets and debts been identified?

☐ Have retirement accounts been adjusted for taxes?

☐ Does each person have realistic monthly cash flow?

☐ Can the spouse keeping the home truly afford it?

☐ Have pensions and retirement accounts been divided fairly?

☐ Does the agreement protect both spouses from debt problems?

☐ Have tax consequences been considered?

☐ Is investment and business risk allocated fairly?

☐ Are deadlines and responsibilities clearly defined?

☐ Will this agreement still make sense five years from now?

If you cannot confidently answer “yes” to each question, it may be worth having your settlement reviewed before signing.

Final Thoughts

A fair divorce settlement is about much more than dividing property.

It is about creating two financially sustainable futures.

Research consistently shows that the financial effects of divorce can last for many years. Taking the time to carefully evaluate your settlement before signing may be one of the most valuable financial decisions you ever make.

You only have one opportunity to negotiate most financial issues in your divorce.

Make sure you understand not only what you are receiving, but what those assets are truly worth and how they will support your future.

At Resilient Divorce Solutions, LLC, my goal is to help individuals and couples make informed financial decisions with confidence. Whether you are participating in divorce mediation, working with an attorney, or negotiating directly, objective financial analysis can help you understand your options and avoid costly mistakes.

If you would like an experienced Certified Divorce Financial Analyst to review your proposed settlement before you sign, I would be honored to help.

Schedule a complimentary consultation to learn how objective financial analysis can help protect your future.


Appendix: Research and Resources

Making informed financial decisions during divorce starts with reliable information. The following resources helped inform this article and may be helpful as you continue learning about the financial side of divorce.

Research on the Financial Impact of Divorce

Gender Differences in the Consequences of Divorce

Read the study

This National Institutes of Health study examines how divorce affects income, wealth, health, and long term financial security. It concludes that divorce often creates larger economic challenges for lower earning spouses, making careful financial planning especially important.

Gender and the Economic Consequences of Divorce in the United States

Full article: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12643126/

This recent study explores how divorce affects people differently based on gender, race, and earning history. The findings reinforce the importance of considering future earning capacity and long term financial stability when negotiating a settlement.

The Economic Consequences of Gray Divorce

Full article: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8599059/

This research focuses on divorce after age 50. The authors found that both men and women experience significant declines in wealth after divorce, with women often experiencing a larger reduction in their standard of living.

Time Cannot Heal All Wounds: Wealth Trajectories of Divorcees

Full article: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9303434/

This study demonstrates that wealth losses following divorce often persist for many years, highlighting why thoughtful financial planning during divorce is so important.

Illinois Law

Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act

Section 503 of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act explains how Illinois courts divide marital property.

Read the Illinois statute:

https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/documents/075000050K503.htm

One important takeaway is that Illinois follows the principle of equitable distribution, which means assets are divided fairly, not necessarily equally.

Learn More About Certified Divorce Financial Analysts

A Certified Divorce Financial Analyst (CDFA®) specializes in analyzing the financial consequences of divorce settlements. A CDFA® can help evaluate settlement options, project long term cash flow, compare after tax values of assets, and identify potential financial risks before agreements are finalized.

Institute for Divorce Financial Analysts

The Institute for Divorce Financial Analysts is the organization that administers the CDFA® designation and provides education for professionals who specialize in divorce finances.

Institute for Divorce Financial Analysts

If you are looking for a CDFA® in your area, you can search the official directory here:

Find a Certified Divorce Financial Analyst

Family Law Resources

American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers

The American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers is a national organization of highly experienced family law attorneys. Their publications and educational resources provide valuable information on divorce, custody, property division, support, and family law developments. (aaml.org)American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *